RESEARCH TRENDS & GAPS ASSESSMENT - WASTEWATER TREATMENT WITH COAGULATION AND FLOCCULATION METHODS
Main Article Content
Artha Dewi Novitasari
Sudarno Sudarno
Nurandani Hardiyanti
Bimastyaji Surya Ramadan
Industrial activities can cause negative impacts, one of which is the result of the production process which can cause pollution and environmental damage if the company does not process B3 waste in accordance with applicable regulations. With increasing concern for the environment, many companies or other interested parties are required to process liquid waste. Therefore, this study aims to find out from several existing research journals about the effectiveness of wastewater treatment methods and processes Poly Aluminum Chloride (PAC) and Aluminum Sulfate (Alum). The analysis method uses several software to find out the results of research analysis from several existing scientific literature. By using blibiometric analysis, it was found that research on wastewater treatment mostly uses coagulation and flocculation methods which have developed every year. To improve the results of wastewater treatment, it is necessary to consider several influencing factors such as dose, speed and duration of stirring during the experiment. From the results of several previous studies, it was found that the use of Poly Aluminum Chloride (PAC) was the most effective compared to Aluminum Sulfate (Alum) by comparing the decrease in the results of testing the specified quality standard parameters (for example pH,COD, BOD, turbidity, TSS, etc)
Abayomi-Alli, A., Abayomi-Alli, O., Misra, S., Fernandez-Sanz, L., 2022. “Study of the Yahoo-Yahoo hash-tag tweets using sentiment analysis and opinion mining algorithms”. Information 13, 152.
Achmad F.R., Sri S., Anik S. 2022, “Pengaruh Variasi PAC, Soda Ash dan Polimer Terhadap Penyisihan pH dan Warna Pada Unit Instalasi Pengolahan Air Minum di Pekanbaru”, Jurnal Ilmu Lingkungan, Vol.20, No.4:769-776.
Alibeigi-Beni, S., Habibi Zare, M., Pourafshari Chenar, M., Sadeghi, M., Shirazian, S., 2021. “Design and optimization of a hybrid process based on hollow-fiber membrane/ coagulation for wastewater treatment”. Environ. Sci. Pollut. Control Ser. 28 (7), 8235–8245.
Alifah A.R., Arifin, Govira C.A., 2022, “Efisiensi Pengolahan Limbah Beton Ready-Mix Dengan Metode Elektrokoagulasi dan Adsorpsi”, Vol.20, No.2:375-381.
Andi Asdiana I.S.Y., Herlina R., Fadlib, Melani G. 2023, “Optimasi Penambahan Polyalumunium Chloride (PAC) dan Waktu Pengadukan Terhadap Kualitas Air Baku (Raw Water) pada PPSDM Migas Cepu”, Jurnal Teknologi Kimia Mineral, 2(1): 22-25.
Ardomoan S.S., Ferri F.G., Nurfitri W., Isna A. 2024, “Penerapan Metode Gabungan Netralisasi, Koagulasi, Filtrasi dan Adsorpsi dalam Pengelolaan Limbah Cair Laboratorium”, Jurnal Teknologi Lingkungan Lahan Basah, Vol. 12, No. 1:097 – 105.
Ari S.S., Putri N.A.H., Sinta S.A., Dodit A. 2022, “Sistem Pengolahan Air Limbah PT Evonik Indonesia Plant Cikarang Wastewater Treatment System PT. Evonik Indonesia Cikarang Plant”, Prosiding SAINTEK: Sains dan Teknologi,Vol.1, No.1.
Audy P.M., Dea K.F., Lisa A. 2024, “Efektivitas Koagulan PAC dan Aluminium Sulfat dengan Kombinasi Flokulan pada Limbah Cair Pabrik Sepeda Motor”, Jurnal Sains dan Edukasi Sains, Vol.7, No.2:90-95.
Behnam Fayyaz Shahandashty, Narges Fallah, Bahram Nasernejad. 2023, “Industrial wastewater treatment: Case study on copper removal from colloidal liquid using coagulation”, Journal of Water Process Engineering 53.
Bili´nska, L., 2017. “Decolorization of Textile Wastewater by Advanced Oxidation Processes (AOPs) under Industrial Conditions: Doctoral Thesis.” Fundacja Rozwoju
Chaojian Ding, Aojie Xie, Ze Yan, Xiyuan Li, Hongfeng Zhang, Na Tang, Xiaocong Wang. 2021, “Treatment of water-based ink wastewater by a novel magnetic flocculant of boron-containing polysilicic acid ferric and zinc sulfate”, Journal of Water Process Engineering, 40-101899.
Chen, W., Zheng, H., Teng, H., Wang, Y., Zhang, Y., Zhao, C., & Liao, Y. 2015, “Enhanced Coagulation-Flocculation Performance of Iron-Based Coagulants: Effects of PO43- and SiO32-“. Modifiers.PLOSONE, 1-20.
Cukri Rahma dan Cukri Rahminiani. 2021, “Penggunaan Tawas (Al2(SO4)3) dalam Menurunkan Kadar Total Suspended Solid Air Limbah Batubara”, Jurnal Optimalisas, Vol.7, P. ISSN: 2477-5479 E. ISSN: 2502-0501.
Diego Gouveia Marques, Janaina de Melo Franco Domingos, Marcelo Antunes Nolasco, Valquíria Campos. 2025, “Textile effluent treatment using coagulation-flocculation and a hydrodynamic cavitation reactor associated with ozonation”. Chemical Engineering Science 304.
Enze Li, Jing Dong, Yongsheng Jia, Zihe Pan, Hongzhou Lv, Zhiping Du, Guandao Gao, Fangqin Cheng. 2024, “Synergistic enhancement of pollutant removal from high-salt wastewater using coagulation-flotation combined process”. Green Chemical Engineering.
Feicheng, M., Yating, L., 2014. “Utilising social network analysis to study the characteristics and functions of the co-occurrence network of online tags. Online Inf”. Rev. 38, 232–247.
Fernando Hymnˆo de Souza, Bruno Segalla Pizzolatti, Maurício Luiz Sens. 2021, “Backwash as a simple operational alternative for small-scale slow sand filters: From conception to the current state of the art”. Journal of Water Process Engineering 40
Gede H.C., Gilang G., Tri M. 2021, “Pengolahan Air Limbah Betalaktam Menggunakan Reagen Kaporit, PAC, dan Alum Sulfat”, Serambi Engineering, Vol.6, No. 3, hal 2066 – 2075.
Hanbai Parka, Sung-il Lima, Hosun Lee, Dal-Sik Woo. 2016, “Water blending effects on coagulation-flocculation using aluminum sulfate (alum), polyaluminum chloride (PAC), and ferric chloride (FeCl3) using multiple water sources”. Desalination and Water Treatment.
Hasan Shaheed, Radin Mohamed, Mohammed Al-Sahari, Nur Shaylinda M., Adel Al-Gheethi, Tuama Alomari. 2020, “Coagulation and flocculation of printing ink effluent using polyaluminium chloride (PAC): optimization and phytotoxicity study”, Desalination Publications, 208:303–311.
Hassiba Zemmouria, Madani Drouichea, Amna Sayeh, Hakim Lounici, Nabil Mameri. 2012, “Coagulation Flocculation Test of Keddara's Water Dam Using Chitosan and Sulfate Aluminium”. Procedia Engineering 33
Heloisa Pereira de S´a Costa, Meuris Gurgel Carlos da Silva, Melissa Gurgel Adeodato Vieira. 2021, “Biosorption of aluminum ions from aqueous solutions using non-conventional low-cost materials: A review”. Journal of Water Process Engineering 40.
Isran A., Setiarto P., Makmur S., Fida I.U. 2023, “Pengolahan Limbah Cair B3 Laboratorium Kimia Menggunakan Metode Kombinasi Koagulasi-Flokulasi dan Filtrasi”, Prosiding Seminar Nasional Teknologi Industri, e-ISSN 2964-1896.
Jiangting Wang, Weiying Xu, Jingjing Xu, Dong Wei, Hui Feng, Zhenghe Xu. 2016, “Effect of aluminum speciation and pH on in-line coagulation/diatomite microfiltration process: Correlations between aggregate characteristics and membrane fouling”. Journal of Molecular Liquids 224 492–501.
Jinjun Deng, Zeyu Gu, Lingmin Wu, Ye Zhang, Yanbin Tong, Fankun Meng, Liqun Sun, Huili Zhang, Hongsheng Liu. 2023, “Efficient purification of graphite industry wastewater by a combined neutralization-coagulation-flocculation process strategy: Performance of flocculant combinations and defluoridation mechanism”, Separation and Purification Technology, 326-124771.
Junhong Yi, Zanmei Chen, Defu Xu, Die Wu, Alan Howard. 2024,“Preparation of a coagulant of polysilicate aluminum ferric from foundry dust and its coagulation performance in treatment of swine wastewater”. Journal of Cleaner Production 434.
Li, C., Liu, Z., Shi, R., 2021. “A bibliometric analysis of 14,822 researches on myocardial reperfusion injury by machine learning”. Int. J. Environ. Res. Publ. Health 18, 8231.
Lingmin Wu, Yixiang Gao, Xiaofei Xu, Jinjun Deng, Hongsheng Liu. 2024, “Excellent coagulation performance of polysilicate aluminum ferric for treating oily wastewater from Daqing gasfield: Responses to polymer properties and coagulation mechanism”. Journal of Environmental Management 356.
Manal F. Abou Taleb, Maha Ali Aljowni, Humaira Parveen, Sayeed Mukhtar. 2024, “Green coagulation and flocculation: Scenedesmus algal extractloaded chitosan/poly(vinyl alcohol) cryogels for effective water treatment”. International Journal of Biological Macromolecules.
Marlinda, Rita Hartati, Yusi Hidjrawa, Kasmawati. 2023, “Optimalisasi Penjernihan Air PDAM Tirta Meulaboh Menggunakan Aluminium Sulfat (Tawas) dan Poly Aluminium Chloride (PAC)”. Jurnal Optimalisasi Vol. 09, No. 01.
Mohr, J.W., Bogdanov, P., 2013. “Introduction—topic models: what they are and why they matter”. Poetics 41, 545–569.
N. Fajri, M. Hadiwidodo, dan A. Rezagama. 2017, “Pengolahan Lindi dengan Metode Koagulasi-Flokulasi Menggunakan Koagulan Aluminium Sulfat dan Metode Ozonisasi untuk Menurunkan Parameter BOD, COD, dan TSS (Studi Kasus Lindi TPA Jatibarang)”, Jurnal Teknik Lingkungan, vol. 6, no. 1, hal. 1–13.
Nada N. Abdulrazzaq, Baseem H. Al-Sabbagh, Haider A. Shanshool. 2021, “Coupling of electrocoagulation and microflotation for the removal of textile dyes from aqueous solutions”. Journal of Water Process Engineering 40.
Nugeraha N., Sumiyati S., & Samudro G. 2010, “Pengolahan Air Limbah Kegiatan Penambangan Batubara Menggunakan Biokoagulan : Studi Penurunan Kadar Tss, Total Fe Dan Total Mn Menggunakan Biji Kelor (Moringa Oleifera)”. Presipitasi, 7(9), 57–61.
Nurdiani. 2020, “Penentuan Optimasi Koagulan PAC dan Alum pada Air Limbah Tekstil Dengan Metode Jar Test”. Warta Akab Vol. 44. No. 1.26-31.
Omer Apaydin, Ugur Kurt, Fatih Ilhan. 2023, “Investigation of the treatability of paint industry wastewater using hybrid coagulant poly-aluminum-chloride-sulfate”. Desalination and Water Treatment.
Pengyu Dong, Jin Li, Akalu M. Woldeyohans, Dries Parmentier, Stijn W.H. Van Hulle. 2024, “Coagulation in combination with anaerobic digestion for enhancement of resource recovery from faecal sludge”. Journal of Environmental Management 358.
Ploypailin Romphophak, Ratchanan Chamnanmor, Pattarasiri Fagkaew, Sermpong Sairiam, Pisut Painmanakul. 2024, “Modelling the predictive analysis of turbidity removal efficiency in the in-line coagulation and flocculation process”. Chemical Engineering Research and Design 210.
Putri Nadia Berliana, Restu Hikmah Ayu Murti, Wahyu Dwi Utomo. 2023, “Kajian Pengelolaan Limbah Bahan Berbahaya dan Beracun (B3) PT. X”. Jurnal Sains dan Teknologi.
Qi Li, Yanyan Zhong, Yalan Zhang, Wei Liu, Yuansong Tian, Tian Qin, Mengting Wu, Wenrong Xiong, Zhiqin Chen, Yuankai Zhou, Xiaohao Guo, Jinying Xu, Sunlin Chi, Yondong Zhang, Zhengyu Jin, Xianchuan Xie. 2025, “Simple synthesis and excellent coagulation performance of a novel red soil-based coagulant”. Separation and Purification Technology 359.
Riskiana Nurjannah, Elida Novita, Sri Wahyuningsih. 2022, “Penentuan Dosis Koagulan pada Musim Hujan di PDAM Jember Unit Tegal Gede”. Repository Universitas Jember Berkala Ilmiah Pertanian.
Rohana, H., & Purwanti, S. T. 2019, “Uji Optimasi Ekstrak Daun Ipomoea Batatas L . Yang Digunakan Sebagai Flokulan Dalam Pengolahan Air Untuk Praktikum Pada Mata Kuliah Kimia Analisis Lingkungan”. Jurnal Inovasi Dan Pengelolaan Laboratorium, 9–20.
Rosalina Hasan dan Aisha Khoirunnisa. 2024 “Efektivitas Koagulan Aluminium Sulfat dan Poly Aluminium Chloride (PAC) pada Pengolahan Limbah Cair B3 PT X”, Warta Akab, Vol.48, No.1, Hal:5-14.
Rosariawari F dan Muhammad M. 2013, “Efektifitas PAC dan Tawas Untuk Menurunkan Kekeruhan Pada Air Permukaan”. Jurnal Ilmiah Teknik Lingkungan Vol.5.
Sarah Goudjil, Saadia Guergazi, Toufik Masmoudi, Samia Achour. 2021, “Effect of reactional parameters on the elimination of Congo Red by the combination of coagulation–floculation with aluminum sulfate”. Desalination and Water Treatment.
Sawassi, A., Khadra, R., 2021. “Bibliometric network analysis of “water systems’ adaptation to climate change uncertainties”: concepts, approaches, gaps, and opportunities.” Sustainability 13, 6738.
Shahandashty B.F., Fallah N., Nasernejad B. 2023, “Industrial wastewater treatment: Case study on copper removal from colloidal liquid using coagulation”. Journal of Water Process Engineering 2214-7144.
Shahin Ghafari, Hamidi Abdul Aziz, Mohamed Hasnain Isa, Ali Akbar Zinatizadeh. 2009, “Application of response surface methodology (RSM) to optimize coagulation–flocculation treatment of leachate using poly-aluminum chloride (PAC) and alum”. Journal of Hazardous Materials 163.
Shargi E.A dan Davarpanah L. 2022, “Optimization of chemical coagulation–flocculation process of detergent manufacturing plant wastewater treatment for full scale applications : a case study”. Desalination and Water Treatment 262 38–53.
Sirikan Noonpui, Paitip Thiravetyan, Woranan Nakbanpote, Suchapa Netpradit. 2010, “Color removal from water-based ink wastewater by bagasse fly ash, sawdust fly ash and activated carbon”. Chemical Engineering Journal 162 503–508.
Sisnayati, Eddyanto W., Yhopie, Selvia A. 2021, “Perbandingan Penggunaan Tawas dan PAC Terhadap Kekeruhan dan pH Air Baku PDAM Tirta Musi Palembang”. Jurnal REDOKS Vol. 6 No. 2. 107-116.
van Eck, N.J., Waltman, L., 2010. “Software survey: VOSviewer, a computer program for bibliometric mapping”. Scientometrics 84, 523–538.
Wei Chena, Huaili Zhenga, Jun Zhaia, Yili Wang, Wenwen Xue, Xiaomin Tang, Zhengan Zhang, Yongjun Sun. 2015, “Characterization and coagulation–flocculation performance of a composite coagulant:poly-ferric-aluminum silicate-sulfate”. Desalination and Water Treatment 56 1776–1786.
Xiang-Juan Ma, Hui-Long Xia. 2009, “Treatment of water-based printing ink wastewater by Fenton process combined with coagulation”. Journal of Hazardous Materials 162 386–390.
Xiaolong Wu, Xian Xiang, Xiaoxu Dong, Guangshuo Chai, Ziman Song, Yongxiang Wang, Jia Liu, Xinpu Han, Yajie Li, Hongbo Liu. 2021, “Profitable wastewater treatment by directly recovering organics for volatile fatty acids production”. Journal of Water Process Engineering 40.
Yao, L., Zhang, Y., Wei, B., Li, L., Wu, F., Zhang, P., Bian, Y., 2016. “Concept over time: the combination of probabilistic topic model with wikipedia knowledge”. Expert Syst. Appl. 60, 27–38.
Yasha Jathan and Eric A. Marchand. 2024, “Enhanced coagulation for removal of dissolved organic nitrogen in water: A review”. Chemosphere 366.
Yonglei Wang, Wentao Sun, Luming Ding, Wei Liu, Liping Tian, Yinhe Zhao, Mengyu Zhang, Xuelin Wang. 2021, “A study on the feasibility and mechanism of enhanced co-coagulation dissolved air flotation with chitosan-modified microbubbles”. Journal of Water Process Engineering 40.
Yoshihiko Matsui, Nobutaka Shirasaki, Takuro Yamaguchi, Kenta Kondo, Kaori Machida, Taiga Fukuura, Taku Matsushita. 2017, “Characteristics and components of poly-aluminum chloride coagulants that enhance arsenate removal by coagulation: Detailed analysis of aluminum species”. Water Research 118.
Yutong Kang, Jie Wang, Zhenjun Li. 2024, “Enhancing pollutants removal in hospital wastewater: Comparative analysis of PAC coagulation vs. bio-contact oxidation, highlighting the impact of outdated treatment plants”. Journal of Hazardous Materials 471.
