CIPP MODEL APPROACH IN EVALUATING VACCINE MONITORING IMPLEMENTATION AT X PUBLIC HEALTH CENTER
Published:
2026-06-16Downloads
Abstract
This study aims to evaluate the implementation of the Electronic Logistics Immunization Monitoring System (SMILE) at the X Community Health Center using the Context, Input, Process, Product (CIPP) model. This research method is qualitative with a descriptive approach. There were 9 informants and data were obtained through in-depth interviews, observations, and document reviews, then analyzed using thematic analysis methods. Based on the results of the context aspect of the study, program needs have been adjusted to a region-based approach to facilitate monitoring of immunization targets, although there are still obstacles in certain target groups. Human resources and infrastructure input are available, but limitations in technical capabilities of officers, double workloads, and internet and electricity connections. The implementation process is in accordance with the SOP, but there are delays in data input due to double recording. The SMILE product has a positive impact on vaccine logistics management and facilitates monitoring of vaccine distribution. Thus, the implementation of the SMILE program at the X Community Health Center has been running quite well, but still requires improving the capabilities of officers, strengthening the network, and optimizing the reporting system to increase program effectiveness.
Keywords:
Program Evaluation SMILE CIPP Vaccine Logistics Community Health CenterReferences
Antariksa, Walid Fajar, Abdul Fattah, and Mutiara Arlisyah Putri Utami. 2022. “Evaluation of the CIPP Model Student Islamic Boarding School Education Program (Context, Input, Process, Product).” Evaluation: Journal of Islamic Education Management 6(1):75–86. doi:10.32478/evaluasi.v6i1.848.
Banks, World. 2023. “Public Disclosure Authorized ASEAN Regional Vaccine Manufacturing and Development.”
Effendi, Diyan E., Indah Pawitaningtyas, Agung D. Laksono, Setia Pranata, and West Java. 2022. “Exploring Factors Contributing to the Slow Covid-19 Vaccine Rollout in Pandeglang District, Indonesia: A Qualitative Study.” 53(Supplement 2):577–94.
Faizin, Afif, and Hesti Kusumaningrum. 2023. “Review of Program Evaluation Models for Online Education and Training.” EduManajerial 1(1):42–54. doi:10.15408/em.v1i1.32245.
Hariyoko, Yusuf, Jehaut, Yanuarius, Dolfianto, and Adi Susiantoro. 2021. “Effectiveness of Public Health Services by Community Health Centers in Manggarai Regency.” Journal of Good Governance 17(2):169–78. doi:10.32834/gg.v17i2.346.
Ministry of Health of the Republic of Indonesia. 2021. “Technical Instructions for the Electronic Immunization and Logistics Monitoring System (SMILE).” 978–79.
Komariah, Siti, Indah Laily Hilmi, Devi Ratnasari, and Ellin Rachmawati. 2022. “Evaluation of Cold Chain Product Distribution at Public Health Centers in Karawang Regency.” 6(2):254–61.
Mardiah, Andri Syahputra, Riska Suci Febriani, and Mudasir Vebri Pradinata Putra. 2023. “Evaluation of the Islamic Education Curriculum.” 2:1–15.
Maurianus, Ans, Lede, Agapitus, H. Kaluge, Simon, Sia, Niha, Damianus, and Talok. 2025. “Educational Program Evaluation Management Using the Context, Input, Process, and Product (CIPP) Model Approach.” 9:67–78.
Muhlisin, Aditya Purbayanti, Ari Yulianto, Meri Rosita, Arpa Pauziah. 2025. “Design of Electronic Medical Record System (RME) for Newborn Vaccine Immunization Reporting Using V-Model Method.” 10.
Rhomaningtias, Lina, Adenda Khairunisa, Shindi Shella May Wara, and Kartika Maulida Hindrayani. 2025. “Sentiment Analysis of Smile Indonesia Application Reviews Using Naive Bayes Method and Support Vector Machine (SVM).” HOAQ (High Education of Organization Archive Quality) : Journal of Information Technology 16(1):79–91. doi:10.52972/hoaq.vol16no1.p79-91.
Rosidah, Ros, Yadi Suryadi, and Seila Azmia. 2025. “Effectiveness of Health Workload According to Medical Records Health Personnel Needs Planning at Manggari Community Health Center in 2025.” 5:3844–59.
License
Copyright (c) 2026 Rudy Chendra, Lutfhiana Nabella, Indah Pasha Palingga, M. Yoga Jusri Pratama, M. Defri Adi Shah Putra
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
